| Update 2: A Google spokesperson says the full-text
issue is not a Google-specific problem. "It is possible for Bloggers to
prevent their full content from showing in Buzz just like in Reader
--it depends on how they set up their feed. If a blog owner wants to
not show their whole blog, they have to use whatever tools they are
using to create their feed to set it to not syndicate the entire post."
Update: So far, Google has referred me to the same response they gave Stay, but I've inquired further. We'll keep you posted.
Original Article: If you were under the
impression that the controversy surrounding Google Buzz was starting to
die down, think again. So far, we've mostly heard about privacy issues, which Google has publicly addressed.
They've also made changes based on user feedback. Now, we're hearing
about possible copyright issues. Google appears to be republishing full
articles without permission, and stripping out any ads that may be in
those articles.
One can easily see why any blogger or publisher wouldn't be very
pleased with this scenario. Not only are they serving up full articles
that others have written without sending authors the traffic or even ad
clicks, but if a user reads the article through Buzz within their Gmail
account, they will likely see the ads Google itself serves.
Blogger Jesse Stay of Stay N' Alive brings the subject up in a post, claiming that this is exactly what is happening to his content. However, Google did respond to him, saying they would "have the ad scraping issue fixed by next week."
That would solve one problem, but presumably, this doesn't change the
fact that they are showing full article text, which is an interesting
choice on Google's part, considering the controversy surrounding how Google News aggregates publishers' content.
That is a different situation entirely, because Google News does not
publish full articles (unless they come from one of their partners).
They simply provide a title, small snippet, and link to the original
source, hence driving traffic to that source. Based on Stay's story,
Google will not likely be driving much traffic by showing full articles
in Buzz. We've contacted Google for comment on this (we'll post when we
receive it).
One might compare reading an article through Buzz to reading one
through a feed reader, like Google Reader. Sometimes you can read a
feed in its full text, but the author has the ability to prevent this.
With Buzz, the full-text articles appear to be coming simply from
people sharing the articles, which is out of the author's control (we
asked Google if their is a way authors can prevent this...again, we'll
post a response when we receive it). -- Chris Crum
|